What is “Marketing Babylon”?

Photo by: Highchunker

following my explanation of why so late to join the party, here is what i believe in, what i wish to be a part of.

Marketing Babylon is a metaphor I find useful in describing the current state of marketing as a discipline and as an activity.

Marketing is broken. It is not merely flawed – wide areas of the practice are quickly deteriorating.
Things that used to work, work no longer: audiences have become incurably elusive, markets endlessly commoditised, mass advertising losing it’s effectiveness even for mass brands. The list goes on.

We are paying the price for decades of marketing hubris, we stand amidst the ruins of an incomprehensible tower of hyped-up, reductive dogmas. Some marketers are desperately clutching their favourite tools, denying the new reality. Many are speaking different languages, distant echoes of outdated methods. More and more of us are looking for a new way.

Marketing needs some creative hacking to remain relevant. Many fundamental ideas are well conceived, but most need to be cut down to size, and separated from the reflexive propaganda of self promoting fads. Out of the rubble and out of the white noise, we can recognise the essence, then carefully select the grains of truth and rewrite a syntax to combine them back into meaningful discourse.

At worse, marketing today is hollow, it’s hypocritical, it’s inconsiderate, it’s loud, it’s corrupt, and so on… And yet, it’s hard to approach any area of business without a close understanding of this increasingly challenging activity. Marketing communications, specifically, remain one of the most prolific, complex and powerful aspects of human sign activity.

Fundamentally, Marketing is, and should be, about communication. It’s about how signs combine into stories and artefacts, and how these are interpreted by the market, and increasingly, fed back by the market.

If the Cluetrain Manifesto is right, and indeed markets are conversations, then marketing should grow to incorporate the theory of those conversations and offer practitioners better communication tools, more dialectical in nature. The convergence of communications, design and technology, is the force accelerating this change, tearing down traditional distinctions between the product, what it communicates and the communication about it:
the brand is the product is the brand is the conversation about the brand, which is about the brand is the product is the brand…
(Distinctions that were fuzzy to begin with)

I believe that a revolution has started, and that it will escalate over the next decade. Fuelled by the rapidly evolving relationship between marketing, design and communications, and their role in business. This change will be led by the people practicing those fields, a group engaging in meaningful, fearless conversation. I hope to make my humble contribution to that decentralised spontaneous movement.

5 thoughts on “What is “Marketing Babylon”?

  1. Hi Uri,

    Its about f**king time! as an enthuse reader of the collective I was really looking forward to something more personal from you. conrgat’ & keep up the good work!

    one small request if i may – perhaps you can write an english and up-to-date post on ‘The info’ ocean’

    very best



  2. Hello Uri,

    First time in your blog. I got here through guy kawasaki blog. So i must tell you, your blog rocks, i study marketing, and as you said, its changing and people dont want to deal with it. The new marketing is rising with marketers like Seth godin, guy kawasaki, etc… i hope that you too, and my conclusion is that it rocks all these new challenges, hope to be there working in it, as you, soon.

    (sorry for the english if its no perfect)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s